It becomes clear to the detectives that the four men have conspired to come up with a false account of what took place the night Hayley disappeared. Jake is assigned to track down Tim Finch’s ex-wife to hear her version of events – and uncovers disturbing information about Chris Lowe’s past. On a personal front, Sunny is offered the opportunity to rekindle his past marriage, and Cassie worries about her father’s failing memory.